• News
  • Sport
  • TV
  • Radio
  • Education
  • TV Licences
  • Contact Us
  • SOUTH AFRICA
  • POLITICS
  • BUSINESS
  • SPORT
  • AFRICA
  • WORLD
  • FEATURES
  • OPINION
No Result
View All Result
1
Home Lifestyle

Push for heterosexual life partners to have same benefits as same-sex couples

17 February 2021, 7:29 AM  |
Angela Bolowana Angela Bolowana |  @SABCNews
Jane Banya has approached the Constitutional Court to confirm the Western Cape High Court ruling in her favour on an inheritance claim.

Jane Banya has approached the Constitutional Court to confirm the Western Cape High Court ruling in her favour on an inheritance claim.

Image: SABC News

Jane Banya has approached the Constitutional Court to confirm the Western Cape High Court ruling in her favour on an inheritance claim.

The Constitutional Court is hearing arguments in a case that seeks to give heterosexual life partners the same benefits as same-sex couples.

Jane Banya has approached the Constitutional Court to confirm the Western Cape High Court ruling in her favour on an inheritance claim.

She had been the life partner of a wealthy Zimbabwean man who died in 2014. But she had been excluded from inheritance because the Intestate Succession Act doesn’t extend the same rights to heterosexual life partners as it does to same sex couples.

The High Court ruled that the Act was unconstitutional and approved Banya’s claim.

It did not approve her claim to maintenance under the Maintenance of Surviving Spouses Act.

She has now asked the Constitutional Court to extend these benefits to her.

Banya’s advocate, Robert Stelzner says, “This case is about benefits which are not extended to survivor of a heterosexual life partnership. Whereas if the survivor had been of the same sex, they would have obtained the benefits under the interstate succession act, under the decision of this court in Laubscher N.O. v Duplan and Another.”

(2/3) Are the definitions of “survivor”, “spouse” and “marriage” in section 1 of the Maintenance of Surviving Spouses Act 27 of 1990 unconstitutional and invalid insofar as they exclude partners in opposite-sex life-partnerships from claiming maintenance in terms of that Act? pic.twitter.com/lfJTOZdd6w

— Constitutional Court (@ConCourtSA) February 15, 2021

The Constitutional Court has questioned whether it would not be overreaching its powers if it declared Section 1 of the Maintenance Act unconstitutional.

“Mr Stelzner, one of the reasons why the majority in Volks vs Robertsons declined to declare section 1 of the Maintenance Act unconstitutional was the view that the regulation of life partnerships would best be handled by Parliament and that brings us to the separation of powers issues….had parliament adopted the domestic partnership bill which was prepared then the applicant and everyone else in a similar position would not have been in front of this court. The only reason we are here is because parliament did not do what this court required it to do,” Justice Leona Theron told Stelzner.

Fifteen years ago the Constitutional Court made a ruling which set in motion processes for parliament to amend the Domestic Partnership legislation to put marriage and committed partnerships on the same level. However, this hasn’t happened yet. Now Banya wants the court to force parliament to move on the matter as Stelzner elaborates.

“Parliament has simply omitted to do that which the court required it to do 15 years ago, there is a gap and that gap we respectfully submit under sec 172 must be filled by the courts including this court otherwise the applicant and those in her position will have to wait who know how long for parliament to get around to discussing and adopting that which the south African law reform commission twice already has spent so much time producing,” says Stelzman.

The Commission for Gender Equality and the Women’s Legal Centre Trust have been admitted as friends of the court in the case. The Women’s Legal Centre Trust drew on numerous case studies to show the impact that the Constitutional Court judgment on this matter will have on a range of women. It included women not represented by the applicant’s particular circumstances. They argued that simply marrying to secure legal protection is not a viable option for many women.

The Gender Commission agreed with the applicant and the Western Cape High Court that the Intestate Succession Act is unconstitutional and that this case is potentially the final step in achieving full and equal protection and recognition of all life partnerships.

Share article
Tags: Constitutional CourtheterosexualSame-sex couples
Previous Post

No wasteful and fruitless expenditure on AstraZeneca vaccine: Mkhize

Next Post

Anti-apartheid activist Ernest Dipale didn’t kill himself: Family

Related Posts

Humpback whales on 
South Africa's picturesque east and west coast.

Plettenberg Bay celebrates World Whale Heritage status ahead of Tourism Month

5 September 2023, 1:51 PM
Humpback whales on 
South Africa's picturesque east and west coast.

South Africa’s east and west coasts witness annual whale migration from Antarctica

24 July 2023, 8:33 AM
Bokamoso Arts Institute at the World Choir Games in Korea.

Bokamoso Chorus greeted with clamour, cheer after being crowned World’s Best Choir

15 July 2023, 11:05 AM
Morning commute traffic streams past the Meta sign outside the headquarters of Facebook parent company Meta Platforms Inc in Mountain View, California, U.S. November 9, 2022.

Meta to launch Twitter-like app Threads

4 July 2023, 7:24 AM
Side view of a bottle with salt...

NRF research shows SA salt restriction legislation effective despite high intake at home

29 June 2023, 12:07 PM
French Musician FKJ.

Popular music festival In the City welcomes French Kiwi Juice to Mzansi

22 June 2023, 6:35 PM
Next Post
Anti-Apartheid, Ernest Moabi Dipale allegedly committed suicide at the then John Vorster Square Police Station in Johannesburg on August 8, 1982, six months after trade unionist, Neil Aggett, died in similar circumstances.

Anti-apartheid activist Ernest Dipale didn't kill himself: Family

Most Viewed

  • 24hrs
  • Week
  • Month
  • Concern over exclusion of foreign nationals from Road Accident Fund
  • Cashless taxi service launched in Cape Town
  • ANC building up in flames in Port St Johns
  • Visitors planning to visit the Overberg region urged to postpone their trips
  • Western Cape on high alert following severe storm warning
  • High waves and rough water conditions force beach closures in the Western Cape
  • Prince Mangosuthu Buthelezi to rest in the town he built and nurtured
  • NSPCA files criminal case against Julius Malema for alleged animal cruelty
  • Snow, heavy rainfall expected in parts of KZN: SAWS
  • Cold-front sweeps across SA bringing snow and chilly temperatures
  • Visitors planning to visit the Overberg region urged to postpone their trips
  • Golden Arrow bus overturns as heavy rains continue in Cape Town
  • Heavy downpour expected in the Eastern Cape
  • Three dead, scores injured in Cape Town bus accident amidst severe weather
  • Significant rainfall helps dam levels in the Nelson Mandela Bay’s drought-stricken areas

LATEST

Residents sit inside a bus in central Stepanakert before leaving Nagorno-Karabakh, a region inhabited by ethnic Armenians, September 25, 2023.
  • World

Ethnic Armenians flee Karabakh after breakaway region’s defeat


The 3rd Biennial African Conference on Fundamental and Applied Physics, ACP2023 hosted by Nelson Mandela University in George, South Africa for the first time.
  • BRICS Summit 2023
  • South Africa

NMU hosts first Biennial Conference on Fundamental and Applied Physics


Amazulu vs Polokwane City
  • Sport

AmaZulu cement it’s spot in DSTV Premiership top 8


  • Politics

Public urged to comment on NPA Amendment Bill


A fence outside the gate facing the National Assembly in Parliament, ripped by strong damaging winds which made landfall on Sunday, captured on 25 September 2023.
  • South Africa

Severe weather plunges Western Cape into chaos


ANC flag.
  • Politics

ANC Eastern Cape mourns death of William Ngozi


Weather

  • About the SABC
  • Contact Us
  • Jobs
  • Advertise
  • Disclaimer
  • Site Map

SABC © 2023

No Result
View All Result
  • SOUTH AFRICA
  • POLITICS
  • BUSINESS
  • SPORT
  • AFRICA
  • WORLD
  • FEATURES
  • OPINION

© 2023

Previous No wasteful and fruitless expenditure on AstraZeneca vaccine: Mkhize
Next Anti-apartheid activist Ernest Dipale didn’t kill himself: Family