• News
  • Sport
  • TV
  • Radio
  • Education
  • TV Licences
  • Contact Us
  • SOUTH AFRICA
  • POLITICS
  • BUSINESS
  • SPORT
  • AFRICA
  • WORLD
  • FEATURES
  • OPINION
No Result
View All Result
1
Home Opinion

Why South Africa’s latest plan for state-owned power giant could work

11 February 2019, 12:12 PM  |
The Conversation The Conversation |  @SABCNews

Lauren Hermanus, University of Cape Town and Catrina Godinho, University of Cape Town

South African President Cyril Ramaphosa has unveiled a new plan for the country’s beleaguered state owned power utility, Eskom. During his State of the Nation Address on 7 February, Ramaphosa announced that Eskom would be unbundled into “three separate entities – generation, transmission and distribution”. These would all be established “under Eskom Holdings”.

This announcement has been a long time coming. It was first proposed and formalised 20 years ago in the country’s 1998 White Paper on Energy Policy. Among other things, the policy sought to break Eskom into distinct smaller entities.

Ramaphosa’s speech was the seventh State of the Nation Address in which a president committed to structural reforms in the electricity sector. Former Presidents Thabo Mbeki and Jacob Zuma made similar promises. Given that they never followed through, Ramaphosa’s announcement may sound all too familiar – and hollow – to some.

But we believe the unbundling will have far reaching consequences for South Africa’s energy sector. Ramaphosa offered a comprehensive outline of the plan. His commitment also comes at a time when Eskom is mired in financial, operational and governance crises. This time, it seems, an electricity reform may really be on the horizon.

Unbundling explained

Unbundling is a type of structural reform. In the electricity sector, vertical unbundling refers to the separation of a utility’s generation, transmission, distribution and (sometimes) retail functions. Horizontal unbundling refers to the creation or entry of multiple players into each of these functions. The players may compete against each other to deliver the same service.

South Africa is certainly not the first country to undergo this type of reform. It can learn from examples of similar processes in countries like Kenya and Uganda.

There are a number of benefits associated with unbundling. These include:

  • more efficiency, resilience and sustainability through a tighter focus and clearer incentives within each functional area;

  • More competition and diversification of players;

  • Clarity in costs and functions of unbundled entities, which increases accountability for the purposes of governance and oversight; and,

  • Low-cost procurement driven by effective planning, competition and transparency.

Eskom currently operates as a vertically integrated monopoly. This means it performs the generation, transmission, distribution and retail functions. Its current structure and governance systems were cemented by apartheid’s internationally isolated security state. This outdated structure, which is characterised by a lack of transparency and accountability, has continued to shape the utility in the years since democracy.

There is a narrow window for municipalities and the private sector to play a role in distribution and retail, and generation, respectively.

But Eskom still generates approximately 95% of the country’s electricity. It exercises tremendous power in controlling access to the national grid. It has used its dominance to oppose national energy policy by, for example, refusing to sign power purchase agreements with independent power producers.

South Africa is lagging behind

This kind of monopolistic structure is unusual by international standards, in both developed and developing countries. And it often comes with operational inefficiencies, bloated costs and poor governance.

Eskom has experienced all of these maladies. This has been demonstrated by its conduct with independent power producers, its role in the controversial nuclear deal, which has now been put on ice, and endemic corruption exposed by the portfolio committee on public enterprises’ inquiry into allegations of state capture at the utility.

These challenges are not unique to South Africa. But the country is behind the curve when it comes to addressing the structural factors and ensuring that its energy sector is well positioned to benefit from technological developments and shifting investment trends.

What Ramaphosa’s announcement means

President Ramaphosa has committed to the full vertical unbundling of Eskom. Generation, transmission and distribution companies will have their own boards and executive structures. This process will take time to implement, probably in the region of five years.

It will require legislative and possibly policy reform. Due to the urgent need for transformation in the sector, the president said immediate attention should be given to the establishment of an independent, state owned transmission grid company.

A good starting point for the unbundling process would be the establishment of an Eskom subsidiary with its own board. This subsidiary would oversee the migration of relevant assets and personnel. The intention would be to combine the transmission, system operation, power planning, procurement and buying functions. This separation is intended to leave the grid company free to contract independent power producers and Eskom generation without the conflict of interest that currently exists. As it stands, Eskom transmission is incentivised to give its own generation plants preference, blocking new technology and new entrants to bolster its own operations.

It’s not only the president’s explicit commitment to a comprehensive reform plan that makes this announcement different from those that came before. The sector is in a fundamentally different situation compared to the early 2000s and early 2010s.

Eskom is in the midst of extreme financial, operational and governance crises which it will not be able to solve alone, especially within the context of the complex global energy transition.

But, to ensure this plan doesn’t go the way of its predecessors, Ramaphosa must ensure meaningful consultation and dialogue with all key stakeholders, as well as credible and sustainable plans to address the needs of all those who may be affected. Without this, the president’s announcement will meet the same fate as previous South African energy policy reform pronouncements. Reform is a complex social and technical process. It is not without risk and costs. This time, however, failure of implementation is not something the country can afford.The Conversation

Lauren Hermanus, Research associate, University of Cape Town and Catrina Godinho, Research associate, University of Cape Town

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Share article
Previous Post

Ismaily reinstated in CAF Champions League after disqualification

Next Post

It was a mistake not to prosecute Zuma: Hofmeyr

Related Posts

A mine

Harry Oppenheimer biography shows the SA mining magnate’s hand in economic policies

1 June 2023, 8:45 PM
BRICS Foreign Ministers meet in Cape Town

Minister Pandor hosts BRICS foreign ministers to thrash out path into the future

31 May 2023, 7:52 PM
A participant stands behind a rainbow flag during a gay pride parade promoting lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender rights, in Chennai, India June 24, 2018.

Being queer in Africa: The state of LGBTIQ+ rights across the continent

29 May 2023, 8:46 PM
FILE PHOTO: Saudi Arabia's Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman shakes hands with Syria's President Bashar al-Assad ahead of the Arab League Summit in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, May 19, 2023.

Saudi embrace of Assad sends strong signal to US

24 May 2023, 7:06 AM
South African money.

Get-rich-quick schemes: Five signs you’re being scammed

22 May 2023, 7:33 PM
FILE PHOTO: Flags are pictured during the first working session of G-7 foreign ministers in Muenster, Germany, November 3, 2022.

OPINION | G7 Hiroshima meeting gathers to counter China’s influence

19 May 2023, 3:48 PM
Next Post
The Deputy National Director of Public Prosecutions Willie Hofmeyr.

It was a mistake not to prosecute Zuma: Hofmeyr

Most Viewed

  • 24hrs
  • Week
  • Month
  • Deadline for Zimbabwean Exemption Permits draws near
  • Durban’s N2 road, Spaghetti Junction closed due to cleanup operations
  • Eastern Cape ActionSA raises eyebrows over qualifications of senior officials
  • Limpopo healthcare set to get massive boost with multi-billion rand hospital
  • Scientist finds solution to extending life of power plants’ rotors
  • Dr Nandipha’s looks during court appearances under the spotlight
  • Deadline for Zimbabwean Exemption Permits draws near
  • Reserve Bank expected to increase repo rate on Thursday
  • Zimbabwe receives 18 helicopters from Russian Federation
  • Durban’s N2 road, Spaghetti Junction closed due to cleanup operations
  • Slain teen Palesa Malatji’s family calls for death sentence to be reinstated
  • 2024 national elections will be a turning point for South Africa: Malema
  • DA joins call for Mabuyane’s resignation
  • COPE calls for urgent removal of Eastern Cape premier
  • One of the victims in Muchipisi village tavern shooting identified

LATEST

Image of the train derailment site in Odisha, India.
  • World

Ramaphosa conveys condolences to India after deadly train crash


South African fire-fighters will be deployed to assist in damping the raging wildfires in the Alberta and Manitoba provinces of Canada.
  • South Africa

Over 200 SA fire-fighters to assist in Canada


Image of amaBhungane logo with interdcit wording overlay.
  • South Africa

AmaBhungane doesn’t have to hand back Moti documents…for now


NPA offices.
  • State capture commission highlights
  • State Capture report
  • South Africa

NPA adopts more aggressive strategy to successfully prosecute cases


ActionSA President, Herman Mashaba speaking as the party's announced former Knysna Speaker, Advocate Julie Anne Lopes will be joining the party.
  • Politics

Mashaba secures new publisher for his book after Mashele funding furore


Durban beachfront.
  • Sport

Swimming and conservation come together to celebrate World Oceans Day


Weather

  • About the SABC
  • Contact Us
  • Jobs
  • Advertise
  • Disclaimer
  • Site Map

SABC © 2023

No Result
View All Result
  • SOUTH AFRICA
  • POLITICS
  • BUSINESS
  • SPORT
  • AFRICA
  • WORLD
  • FEATURES
  • OPINION

© 2023

Previous Ismaily goalkeeper. Ismaily reinstated in CAF Champions League after disqualification
Next The Deputy National Director of Public Prosecutions Willie Hofmeyr. It was a mistake not to prosecute Zuma: Hofmeyr