Princess Masindi Mphephu has challenged the High Court ruling which recognised her uncle Toni Mphephu-Ramabulana as the rightful VhaVenda king.
The tug-of-war that divided the VhaVenda nation has been going on for six years. Princess Masindi argues the Customary Law that favours first-born male children violates her right to equality – a right which is guaranteed in the Section 9 of the Constitution.
Her uncle, Mphephu-Ramabulana, is adamant that the Kingship is decided based on tradition and not gender.
Legal expert, Lebohang Mokhele, says that Customary Law has to comply with the constitution.
“The question of Customary Law is recognised and it also has to comply with the constitution and even in the application and practices of the principles of Customary Law, they also have to be done in the framework of the constitution. Knowing that the constitution is the supreme law of South Africa and the Customary Law will be the secondary law, where indigenous laws are concerned and where African laws are then concerned.”
In September 2016, Princess Masindi successfully got the court to halt former President Jacob Zuma’s plans to crown the king, pending the finality of the current legal stand-off.
Princess Masindi contends that former Zuma did not consider the existing Customary Law when he applied the rule of male primogeniture. This led to the recognition of Mphephu-Ramabulana as the rightful king.
The Princess is the daughter of the late VhaVenda paramount chief, Tshimangadzo Dimbanyika Mphephu.
Chief Tshimangadzo Mphephu reigned from 1994 until he died in a car crash in December 1997. His younger brother, Toni, was installed as the new King and was given the title of King Mphephu-Ramabulana.
WATCH RELATED VIDEO BELOW: