• News
  • Sport
  • TV
  • Radio
  • Education
  • TV Licences
  • Contact Us
  • SOUTH AFRICA
  • POLITICS
  • BUSINESS
  • SPORT
  • AFRICA
  • WORLD
  • FEATURES
  • OPINION
No Result
View All Result
1
Home Politics

Nxasana ‘had no choice but to accept R17 million cash settlement’, Concourt hears

28 February 2018, 8:30 PM  |
ANA ANA |  @SABCNews

Image: SABC

Former National Prosecutions Authority (NPA) boss Mxolisi Nxasana was entitled to the R17 million golden handshake he received to vacate his post as he was subjected to very difficult circumstances by former South African president Jacob Zuma, the Constitutional Court heard on Wednesday.

Nxasana’s advocate Michelle Le Roux argued that her client faced an “untenable situation” where NPA senior officials such as Nomgcobo Jiba allegedly plotted against him by interacting directly with Zuma.

“He [Nxasana] put the NPA above himself for the country and for the stability of the NPA…that is why he ultimately decided to do this…perhaps it is easier for us to sit here and question why did he not stick it out and reject the payment,” Le Roux told the court.

“He explored every avenue that could improve his situation to absolutely no avail — he brought in retired justice [Zak Yacoob who completed an investigation into the NPA] hoping the president would listen to them, he got honourable members in the NPA to make submissions to the minister that things needed to change.”

Justice Johan Froneman interjected: “I accept all that and I have sympathy for him…couldn’t he not refuse to settle?”

Le Roux responded asking: “If we were truly reflective, I am not sure how many people would endure that two years and sign up for another eight. I think that is the just and equitable part that this remedy takes into account…if we put ourselves in his shoes, could we seriously expect him to continue for another eight years?”

“He was facing a commission of inquiry, high court litigation, a campaign against him where the police were sent to find dirt on him…could he endure that for a further eight years?…he took the president to court so he can stop interfering with his work, and stop threatening him with an inquiry.”

The justice minister and Zuma failed Nxasana, she added.

“It came to a point where he said I am here as per my contract, I am being prevented from doing my job by the number one citizen in the land. So he was ultimately entitled to his contractual worth…his position was — you want me out, then I am entitled to the value of the contract.”

Le Roux argued that Nxasana agreed to pay back the R17 million and continued assisting parties to get to the bottom of what happened in the long drawn case.

In December last year, the North Gauteng High Court set aside current NPA boss Shaun Abrahams’ appointment as National Director of Public Prosecutions (NDPP) and ruled that President Cyril Ramaphosa appoint a new NPA boss, and that Nxasana repay the golden handshake.

Nxasana’s affidavit to the high court, in which Le Roux said contained evidence of communication trail between Nxasana and Zuma, was rejected by the court because it was filed too late.

Nxasana is appealing the high court’s refusal to admit his affidavit, he wants the Constitutional Court to admit his condonation so that his version of the events can be heard. Le Roux said it was unfair for the high court to label her client as “a man with a price” and that he committed to paying back the money.

However, Hiton Epstein, for the NPA, argued that Nxasana, after taking the payment and leaving the NPA in June 2015, never sought to return.

He asked where was the R17 million was that Nxasana had been promising to pay back.

“The first time he indicated he wanted to return was only in August 2017…he sat back for more than two years, content to keep the money. But the State should be saying ‘show me the money’…where is the money he got? He keeps tendering that he will pay it back but he is still here today talking about paying it back,” said Epstein.

“The court should note that not only did he get the R17 million, he received his pension and leave benefits.”
Epstein said his client agreed with the high court that the golden handshake was unlawful.

“It is irrational to use public funds to pay someone upfront to leave, including his pension. That is an absolute abuse of power…especially that the most he could have got was just his pension.”

Abrahams and the NPA are appealing the high court decision nullifying Abraham’s appointment, arguing that his appointment was valid and that the high court erred in its decision.

Judgment was reserved.

Share article
Tags: NPAConCourtShaun AbrahamMxolisi NxasanaJacob Zuma
Previous Post

Washington pauses as Reverend Billy Graham lies in honor

Next Post

Four U.N. peacekeepers killed in roadside explosion in Mali

Related Posts

ANC stalwart Aziz Pahad remembered for contributions to Middle East policy

27 September 2023, 10:30 PM
File Image: SAPS vehicles and a police tape.

7 000 SAPS members criminally charged for violent crimes: Cele

27 September 2023, 9:06 PM
The late Aziz Pahad gesturing during an event

Aziz Pahad: A Life of Activism and Diplomacy

27 September 2023, 8:50 PM
Aziz Pahad addressing an event

Anti-apartheid activist Aziz Pahad passes on

27 September 2023, 8:04 PM
[FILE IMAGE] A police vehicle on patrol

FF Plus calls for cleaning up of the police service

27 September 2023, 4:29 PM
Nelson Mandela Bay Metro council.

Nelson Mandela Bay Council to debate City Manager’s future

27 September 2023, 2:24 PM
Next Post

Four U.N. peacekeepers killed in roadside explosion in Mali

Most Viewed

  • 24hrs
  • Week
  • Month
  • Concern over exclusion of foreign nationals from Road Accident Fund
  • Visitors planning to visit the Overberg region urged to postpone their trips
  • ANC building up in flames in Port St Johns
  • Western Cape on high alert following severe storm warning
  • Steam trains revived in the Western Cape amid Heritage Day celebrations
  • High waves and rough water conditions force beach closures in the Western Cape
  • Prince Mangosuthu Buthelezi to rest in the town he built and nurtured
  • NSPCA files criminal case against Julius Malema for alleged animal cruelty
  • Snow, heavy rainfall expected in parts of KZN: SAWS
  • Cold-front sweeps across SA bringing snow and chilly temperatures
  • Anti-apartheid activist Aziz Pahad passes on
  • KZN coastal areas on high alert as level 4 inclement weather warning issued
  • Technology making a significant impact in rhino poaching reduction
  • Many Western Cape roads remain inaccessible
  • ‘Medupi power station has turned the corner’

LATEST

  • Politics

ANC stalwart Aziz Pahad remembered for contributions to Middle East policy


People gather at the site following a fatal fire at a wedding celebration, in the district of Hamdaniya in Iraq's Nineveh province, Iraq, September 27, 2023.
  • World

Iraq wedding fire kills more than 100


[FILE IMAGE] Cars are overturned at Johannesburg CBD due to an explosion.
  • Business

Local govt’s inability to enforce by-laws blamed for decay of SA cities


File Image: SAPS vehicles and a police tape.
  • Politics

7 000 SAPS members criminally charged for violent crimes: Cele


Handre Pollard kicking
  • Sport

Pollard back as Boks rotate team for Tonga clash


The late Aziz Pahad gesturing during an event
  • Politics

Aziz Pahad: A Life of Activism and Diplomacy


Weather

  • About the SABC
  • Contact Us
  • Jobs
  • Advertise
  • Disclaimer
  • Site Map

SABC © 2023

No Result
View All Result
  • SOUTH AFRICA
  • POLITICS
  • BUSINESS
  • SPORT
  • AFRICA
  • WORLD
  • FEATURES
  • OPINION

© 2023

Previous Washington pauses as Reverend Billy Graham lies in honor
Next Four U.N. peacekeepers killed in roadside explosion in Mali