• News
  • Sport
  • TV
  • Radio
  • Education
  • TV Licences
  • Contact Us
  • SOUTH AFRICA
  • POLITICS
  • BUSINESS
  • SPORT
  • AFRICA
  • WORLD
  • FEATURES
  • OPINION
No Result
View All Result
1
Home Politics

‘Maughan might have reasonable argument in challenging private prosecution’

2 February 2023, 3:37 PM  |
Nonjabulo Mntungwa-Makamu Nonjabulo Mntungwa-Makamu |  @SABCNews
A gavel used by judges in the court of law.

A gavel used by judges in the court of law.

Image: Reuters

A gavel used by judges in the court of law.

Former President Jacob Zuma’s private prosecution case against state prosecutor Advocate Billy Downer and legal journalist Karyn Maughan has been adjourned to the 4th of August in the Pietermaritzburg High Court.

This is to allow the court to deal with Maughan and Downer’s application to have the private prosecution set aside. This application will be heard in March.

Downer and Maughan who face criminal charges in terms of the NPA Act appeared briefly before Judge Emmanuel Chili in the Pietermaritzburg High Court.

Zuma has instituted a private proseuction against them for allegedly unlawfully disclosing private documents. According to Zuma, Downer leaked his medical records to Maughan in his arms deal corruption case. In her application to have the private prosecution set aside, Maughan argues in court papers that Zuma did not obtain a nolle prosequi certificate against her. She says it was only obtained against Downer.

Legal expert, attorney Melusi Xulu says Maughan might have a reasonable argument in challenging the private prosecution.

“There is no mention of Miss Maughan but when you come to court then she’s added she might say but you know this is like she’s been saying it is an infringement of her rights to freedom of expression and she’s being harassed but we have to look at the fact that generally how it must be done when there is private prosecution. I think that is interesting thing, we will hear from the private prosecution team why did they add her at a later stage. This is my view if it was an afterthought to add her maybe they should have not brought the case to court but maybe that the matter to the police again to add her to get that second nolle prosecution certificate,” says Xulu.

Xulu adds that it would be impossible to continue with the private prosecution before the applications brought by the accused have been heard.

“It makes sense because I think both of them brought applications not only accuse 1 and accuse 2, they have to have time to deal with the application which they are raising to set aside the private prosecution. Then if they are not set aside on the 4th of August the process for private prosecution will obviously begin. We will have to wait until then to hear what the decision will be made before August. We don’t see anything being done much, we don’t see any finalization of this matter today because there are lots of issues, this case is connected to the arms deal and other issues, so it has to be dealt with and needs time for it to be dealt with sufficiently,” Xulu adds.

Postponing the matter, Judge Emmanuel Chili indicated that all parties agreed that Maughan and Downer’s applications needed to be heard first.

“It has been agreed and it is so ordered that the matter be adjourned to 4 August 2023. You are warned to appear in court on that date at 9:30 in the morning and remain in court until your name has been called out if you do not do that a warrant of arrest will be authorized by the way,” says Judge Chili.

The Pietermaritzburg High Court is expected to hear the applications to have the case set aside in mid-March. The judge who will hear the applications is yet to be announced.-Additional reporting by Nonkululeko Hlophe

Share article
Tags: The Pietermaritzburg High CourtState Prosecutor Advocate Billy Downer and legal journalist Karyn Maughan
Previous Post

President criticised for delay in SABC board appointment

Next Post

France defender Varane retires from international football

Related Posts

LIVE: Zuma’s private prosecution matter against Downer, Maughan

22 March 2023, 9:35 AM

VIDEO | President Ramaphosa addresses National Conference on the Constitution

22 March 2023, 9:21 AM
File Image: Former President Jacob Zuma seen seated in court.

Zuma vs Adv Downer and Maughan court case to hear counter arguments

22 March 2023, 5:17 AM
SACP General Secretary Solly Mapaila addressing the party's congress

SACP describes EFF’s national shutdown as a victory

21 March 2023, 10:13 PM
Senior ANC member Susan Shabangu

Shabangu deplores growing racism in the ANC

21 March 2023, 9:45 PM
Prince Buthelezi was also applauded for his role in ensuring that traditional leadership is well respected across the continent

Africa needs strong political leaders to progress: Obasanjo

21 March 2023, 9:32 PM
Next Post
[File Image] : France's Raphael Varane and Karim Benzema during training

France defender Varane retires from international football

Most Viewed

  • 24hrs
  • Week
  • Month
  • NPA’s Andrew Breitenbach admits to leaking Zuma medical records to Maughan
  • SABC News crew attacked on N2 while monitoring protests
  • BREAKING | EFF members arrested after clashes with police in Braamfontein Sunday night
  • WARNING | Graphic details: Mabopane businessman killed in a hail of bullets
  • Police making progress in AKA’s murder case
  • Corporates prepare for a possible national blackout
  • NPA’s Andrew Breitenbach admits to leaking Zuma medical records to Maughan
  • SABC News crew attacked on N2 while monitoring protests
  • Wits SRC sued
  • E-tolls permanently scrapped: Lesufi
  • Two taxi owners assassinated in Durban
  • AmaZulu King pays tribute to Prince Mangosuthu Buthelezi
  • Shabangu deplores growing racism in the ANC
  • Problems at Kusile have nothing to do with corruption: Ramokgopa
  • Drive-by shooting in Durban kills two, injures teenage girl

LATEST

Food packed in a supermarket’s fridge.
  • Business

Food inflation increases to all-time high


SAPS personnel at a roadblock
  • National shutdown
  • South Africa

Visible policing helped manage national shutdown: Cele


Powerlines leading from the Koeberg Nuclear Power Station
  • Eskom rolling blackouts
  • Business

Black Business Council optimistic about Eskom turnaround


  • Politics

LIVE: Zuma’s private prosecution matter against Downer, Maughan


  • Politics

VIDEO | President Ramaphosa addresses National Conference on the Constitution


Aerial view of the Koeberg Nuclear Power Station
  • Eskom rolling blackouts
  • Business

320-ton steam generator removed at Koeberg Power Station


Weather

  • About the SABC
  • Contact Us
  • Jobs
  • Advertise
  • Disclaimer
  • Site Map

SABC © 2023

No Result
View All Result
  • SOUTH AFRICA
  • POLITICS
  • BUSINESS
  • SPORT
  • AFRICA
  • WORLD
  • FEATURES
  • OPINION

© 2023

Previous President criticised for delay in SABC board appointment
Next France defender Varane retires from international football