Largest Palestinian displacement in decades looms after Israeli court ruling

Some 1,200 Palestinians in the occupied West Bank region of Masafer Yatta face the risk of forced removal to make way for an army firing zone after a decades-long legal battle that ended last month at the Supreme Court of Israel.

The ruling made way for one of the largest displacements since Israel captured the territory in the 1967 Middle East war; but residents are refusing to leave, hoping their resilience and international pressure will keep Israel from carrying out the evictions.

Much of the argument during the lengthy case centred on whether the Palestinians who live across the area are permanent residents or seasonal occupants.

In the 1980s, Israel declared the area a closed military zone known as “Firing Zone 918”. It argued in court that these 3,000 hectares along the Israel-West Bank boundary were “highly crucial” for training purposes and that the Palestinians living there were only seasonal dwellers.

The Supreme Court concluded that the residents “failed to prove their claim of permanent habitation” before the area was declared a firing zone. It relied on aerial photos and excerpts from a 1985 book that both sides cited as evidence.

The book, titled “Life in the Caves of Mount Hebron”, was authored by Israeli anthropologist Yaacov Havakook, who spent three years studying the lives of Palestinian farmers and shepherds in Masafer Yatta.

Havakook declined to comment and instead referred journalists to his book. However, the anthropologist said he had tried to submit an expert opinion on behalf of the residents following a request from one of their lawyers, and was prevented from doing so by the Israel’s Ministry of Defense where he was employed at the time.

Verdict devastates residents

The communities in this part of the South Hebron Hills traditionally lived in underground caves. Over the past two decades, they have also begun building tin shacks and small rooms above ground.

According to residents, Israeli forces have been demolishing these new constructions for years, and now that they have the backing of the highest court in Israel, the evictions are likely to pick up.

“They want to take this land from us to build settlements,” said Wadha Ayoub Abu Sabha, a resident of al-Fakheit, one of a group of villages where Palestinian shepherds and farmers claim a historic connection to the land.

“We’re not leaving,” she said.

International Criticism

The United Nations and European Union have condemned the court ruling and urged Israel to stop the demolitions and evictions.

“The establishment of a firing zone cannot be considered an ‘imperative military reason’ to transfer the population under occupation,” the EU spokesperson said in a statement.

In a transcript of a 1981 ministerial meeting on settlements uncovered by Israeli researchers, then-Agriculture Minister Ariel Sharon -who later became prime minister- suggested the Israeli military expand training zones in the South Hebron Hills to dispossess the Palestinian residents of their land.

“We want to offer you more training zones,” Sharon said, given “the spread of Arab villagers from the hills toward the desert”.

The Israeli military told Reuters the area was declared a firing zone for “a variety of relevant operational considerations” and that Palestinians violated the closure order by building without permits over the years.

According to the United Nations, the Israeli authorities reject most Palestinian applications for building permits in “Area C”, a swathe of land making up two-thirds of the West Bank where Israel has full control and where most Jewish settlements are located. In other areas of the West Bank, Palestinians exercise limited self-rule.

UN data also showed that Israel has marked nearly 30% of Area C as military firing zones. The designations have put 38 of the most vulnerable Palestinian communities at increased risk of forced displacement.

Meanwhile, settlements in the area have continued to expand, further restricting Palestinian movement and the space available for residents to farm and graze their sheep and goats.