• News
  • Sport
  • TV
  • Radio
  • Education
  • TV Licences
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • SOUTH AFRICA
  • POLITICS
  • BUSINESS
  • SPORT
  • AFRICA
  • WORLD
  • SCI-TECH
  • LIFESTYLE
  • FEATURES
  • OPINION
Home Politics

HR manager testifies that Mkhwebane wanted former spokesperson removed for calling her Busisiwe

17 August 2022, 10:05 PM  |
Mercedes Besent Mercedes Besent |  @SABCNews
Suspended Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane’s at Committee Room M46 during lunch break attending the proceedings of the Section 194 Inquiry into her fitness to hold office, 17 August 2022.

Suspended Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane’s at Committee Room M46 during lunch break attending the proceedings of the Section 194 Inquiry into her fitness to hold office, 17 August 2022.

Image: Mercedes Besent

Suspended Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane’s at Committee Room M46 during lunch break attending the proceedings of the Section 194 Inquiry into her fitness to hold office, 17 August 2022.

Suspended Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane allegedly instructed that former spokesperson Cleo Mosana should be removed from her Private Office for not doing her work and for calling Mkhwebane by her first name, Busisiwe. This was revealed at the Section 194 Parliamentary Inquiry into Mkhwebane’s fitness to hold office when Acting Head of Corporate Services and Human Resource Manager in the Office of the Public Protector Gumbi Tyelela was testifying.

However, Tyelela faced intense questions from ANC MP Sahlulele Luzipo on the matter. Luzipo wanted to know what Tyelela did as an HR practitioner to refuse an instruction that may have been irregular if there was such an instruction.

He also wanted to know if such an instruction was given in writing. Luzipo says as an HR practitioner, Tyelela’s responsibility is to follow the HR rules. Tyelela was quizzed by MPs after cross examination from Mkhwebane’s  legal representative Dali Mpofu.

During his testimony, it was revealed that Mosana, who has since resigned, was demoted. At the centre of human resource concerns in the PP’s office were allegations of victimisation, intimidation, harassment of staff. This also forms part of the charge in the motion to investigate Mkhwebane for her fitness to hold office.

During clarity seeking questions, Tyelela’s human resource and labour relations know how came into question in an interaction with Luzipo.

” Mr Tyelela can I assume or endorse you as someone who by where you are located is someone who understood to understands to the best of that institution, how labour relations and human resource matters are supposed to unfold,” Luzipo asked Tyelela.

” Yes I believe so,” responded Tyelela.

Luzipo: ” Ok. I won’t read this part but I want to start to (at paragraph) 64. And on 64 I want to start on the second question. It says present was both Miss Mosana and then Chief of staff Linda Molelekoa. The PP came in  she was upset, indicated that she no longer wanted to work with Miss Mosana and she (Mosana) did not want to be doing her work, and that Miss Mosana was disrespecting her by calling her by her first name Busisiwe. Now,  what do you call that incident? “, asked Luzipo.

Tyelela replies: “I am not sure if I understand the question……Well, it was a meeting where PP raised her unhappiness about the spokesperson.”

Luzipo was not convinced: ” No no, I am trying to read because, from when you read below, definitely as a public servant, we don’t want to assume. I don’t get something here that says you were then instructed. If there was something, but there is a process after the incident of what had happened, that’s why I’m asking what do you call what happened on that day in terms of Public Service Code of Conduct?”

Tyelela answers again: “I am not sure if I understand the question. On that day as I indicated in my affidavit, PP that she said the issue was that she was unhappy and then she said uCleo must go home to serve notice. That is where then I intervened”

Luzipo: “But I can’t find something that says she (Mkhwebane) was unhappy. You said she was upset and indicated that, – let’s use the words that are used and indicated that she no longer wanted to work with Miss Mosana, that’s what is here”

Tyelela: “That’s  correct , yes.  Well I’m saying to me it means the same thing.

Luzipo continued to probe:  ” Ok let me lead you. In terms of the rules of fairness and equity, and proper public service conduct,  and you are a senior  official in the Public Service. What should you have done, or will I be wrong to say that if it was an instruction or you understood to have been an instruction, you should have requested the Public Protector to put it in writing. According to you if it was an instruction was it indeed an irregular instruction, does Public Service not instruct you to request your superior to put that in writing?”

Tyelela: ” That could be one way of doing it butt but we felt that we could correct it by taking it over from the PP and deal with the matter,”

Luzipo: ” So, you don’t take it that as if it was an instruction?”

Tyelela again: ” Yes…….You could say it was an instruction, because she actually said she must go but we indicated that she cannot do that.”

Luzipo: “As a senior Public Service practitioner the rules you know. Don’t they say if that instruction coming to what you say,- because one could argue and say, you (Tyelela) then facilitated an irregular instruction that  have led to someone losing her job”

Tyelela: ” Well my understanding is that we were correcting what PP wanted to do which was incorrect”

Luzipo: ” No, no no,  the point here is that you are a Public Service practitioner in human resource practice. Not the Public Protector. It’s you. I am asking didn’t you believe that the instruction was irregular and you facilitated,  and when you facilitated you then, that’s the action you take, is then to agree on demotion. The rules again are straight forward. On what ground (did you follow the instruction)?, there are only two grounds you can take a person, is on misconduct, gross misconduct or incapacity as far as I know. On which human resource rule the procedure you followed as a person I treat, is highly an expert?”

Tyelela: ” Well in terms of what PP was saying, if PP was not happy with the work of Miss Mosana, if Miss Mosana was not delivering on what was expected of her, that would fall under misconduct.”

Luzipo ended: ” My last point is just simple. Is there any evidence you can present that you have requested a written instruction on what you believe is an irregular instruction, because if you know Mr Mahlangu, I can’t find anything what that was said to you, not what as this committee, can be an evidence to be used that you acted according to  what is expected of a person of yourself on the office that you occupy”

Tyelela:  ” Well.. I did not tell the committee that I requested for a written instruction, so there will be no evidence to that because I did not request for it”

Securitisation of the Public Protector’s office

Allegations of the involvement of the State Security Agency and the general securitisation of the Public Protector’s Office since Mkhwebane took office, continued to come under the spotlight. Towards the end, Committee Chairperson Richard Dyantyi also sought further clarity from Tyelela.

” There are issues that you can assist me to help me just understand better. Honourable (Kevin) Mileham asked you a question about the view that securitisation of the office happened at the arrival of the Public Protector Advocate Busisiwe Mkhwebane. And you answered that in the affirmative in a response. The first thing I want to  know that you can assist this committee with, what are the features of a securitised institution”, Dyantyi asked.

Tyelela replied: ” One example I can make is that we did not have a standalone security management unit. It was part of facilities and logistics. Then when PP came, it became a separate independent unit, with a senior manager. There was no senior manager before in security. That is one example”

Reginald Ndou to testify next

One of the senior managers in the Office of the Public Protector Reginald Ndou is expected to take the stand on Thursday morning.

Ndou is expected to be questioned extensively about various issues. These include claims that he had instructed that the so-called Gupta Leaks not be included in the Vrede Dairy report. He is further expected to be questioned about a case of sexual harassment that was laid against him.

Share article
Previous Post

DA refutes claims by ActionSA against Tshwane Mayor over R26 bln bid

Next Post

Billionaire Ratcliffe interested in buying Manchester United – Source

Related Posts

[File Image] ANC President Cyril Ramaphosa addresses community members during the  Letsema campaign.

ANC aims to set up ‘Delivery Command Centre’

31 January 2023, 6:03 AM
Suspended Public Protector Busiswe Mkhwebane.

Zulu-Sokoni emphasises significance of shielding Public Protector’s Office from executive meddling

30 January 2023, 9:38 PM

ANC’s Lekgotla seeks to declare SA’s energy crisis a national disaster: Ramaphosa

30 January 2023, 7:30 PM
File Image: Former President Jacob Zuma seen seated in court.

Judge Chilli takes over Zuma corruption trial

30 January 2023, 3:09 PM
[File image]: Former President Jacob Zuma.

Zuma trial: ‘Judge Koen’s recusal protects integrity of case’

30 January 2023, 1:13 PM
Former Johannesburg mayor Dr Mpho Phalatse

Phalatse wants DA top job

30 January 2023, 12:57 PM
Next Post
Man United logo seen on a field

Billionaire Ratcliffe interested in buying Manchester United - Source

Most Viewed

  • 24hrs
  • Week
  • Month
  • Gas leak shut, isolated in Pretoria North
  • King of Bacardi music Itumeleng Mosoeu “Vusi Ma R5” killed in Soshanguve
  • Bapedi kingdom commemorates Kgosi Mampuru II, still hoping to find his remains
  • Limpopo man arrested after discovery of his wife’s body in water-filled pit toilet
  • EFF cuts ties with IFP in KwaZulu-Natal
  • Parts of the Northern Cape to be exempted from rolling blackouts
  • VIDEO | St Benedict College’s Matric learner gets 11 distinctions
  • Limpopo matriculant from child-headed household attains diploma pass
  • Female circumcision practice thriving in Eastern Cape
  • Premier denies claims that KZN government spent millions on Mampintsha’s funeral
  • King of Bacardi music Itumeleng Mosoeu “Vusi Ma R5” killed in Soshanguve
  • KwaZakhele mass shooting death toll rises to eight
  • KwaZakhele birthday party mass shooting leaves seven dead, four wounded
  • VIDEO: Judge Piet Koen recuses himself from Zuma Corruption Trial
  • VIDEO: Livhuwani Madadzhe remanded in custody, murder case postponed to Tuesday

LATEST

[File Image] ANC President Cyril Ramaphosa addresses community members during the  Letsema campaign.
  • Politics

ANC aims to set up ‘Delivery Command Centre’


The Garden Route Food Pantry is encouraging those who are able to sponsor these meals for those who cannot afford them.
  • Lifestyle

Western Cape NGO develops new product ‘Food Sock’ to help end hunger


[File image]  Water being poured into a container.
  • South Africa

Water scarcity reported in parts of Johannesburg and Tshwane


Suspended Public Protector Busiswe Mkhwebane.
  • Politics

Zulu-Sokoni emphasises significance of shielding Public Protector’s Office from executive meddling


Africa's rhino population has been decimated over the decades to feed demand for rhino horn, which, despite being made of the same stuff as rhino hair and fingernails, is prized in East Asia as a supposed medicine and as jewellery.
  • Africa

Namibia rhino poaching surged 93% in 2022


The dollar index has weakened to 101.88 from a 20-year high of 114.78 on September 28 as investors price in the likelihood that the Fed is nearing the end of its tightening cycle.
  • Business

Dollar steady as central banks take central stage


Weather

  • About the SABC
  • Contact Us
  • Jobs
  • Advertise
  • Disclaimer
  • Site Map

SABC © 2022

No Result
View All Result
  • SOUTH AFRICA
  • POLITICS
  • BUSINESS
  • SPORT
  • AFRICA
  • WORLD
  • SCI-TECH
  • LIFESTYLE
  • FEATURES
  • OPINION

© 2022

Previous DA refutes claims by ActionSA against Tshwane Mayor over R26 bln bid
Next Billionaire Ratcliffe interested in buying Manchester United – Source