Constitutional court dismisses Moyane’s application

Tom Moyane
Reading Time: 2 minutes

Former South African Revenue Service (SARS) Commissioner Tom Moyane’s bid to regain his job has failed at the Constitutional Court, which said the court application had no reasonable prospect of success.

Moyane was fired by President Cyril Ramaphosa on Judge Robert Nugent’s recommendation. The Nugent Commission of Inquiry had found that Moyane’s tenure at the revenue service was characterised by financial misconduct, mismanagement and losses in tax revenue collection of over R50 billion.

Moyane approached the High Court in Pretoria and asked the court to reverse the President’s decision to fire him. He also wanted the court to prohibit Nugent from delivering his final report to the president.

But that application was dismissed and he later approached the Constitutional Court.

Following Tuesday’s decision President Ramaphosa can now appoint a new SARS commissioner.

Meanwhile, economist Azar Jammine, has warned that it will take many years for SARS to recover from the rule of Moyane.

 Finance Minister Tito Mboweni has appointed a panel to recommend to Ramaphosa, a shortlist of new candidates. Trevor Manuel and Judge Dennis Davis are on the panel.

Jammine says it will take years to turn SARS around,”The decline in governance at the South African revenue services has resulted in a huge leakage of tax collection and inflow of illicit products into the country at major tax payers cost.  The only thing that one must bear in mind is that the turnaround is likely to take years rather than months.  A lot of damage has been inflicted on the organisation over the last five years.”

Watch related video below for more on the story: