• News
  • Sport
  • TV
  • Radio
  • Education
  • TV Licences
  • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • SOUTH AFRICA
  • POLITICS
  • BUSINESS
  • SPORT
  • AFRICA
  • WORLD
  • SCI-TECH
  • LIFESTYLE
  • FEATURES
  • OPINION
Home World

At Catalan separatist trial, judge Marchena walks tightrope

20 February 2019, 5:24 PM  |
AFP AFP |  @SABCNews
Catalan regional president Quim Torra (R) and Former Catalan president Carles Puigdemont (L) attend a press conference in Brussels.

Catalan regional president Quim Torra (R) and Former Catalan president Carles Puigdemont (L) attend a press conference in Brussels.

Image: AFP

Catalan regional president Quim Torra (R) and Former Catalan president Carles Puigdemont (L) attend a press conference in Brussels.

At the helm of the hugely divisive trial of Catalan separatist leaders, Supreme Court judge Manuel Marchena is performing a difficult balancing act, alternating firmness and leniency in live proceedings.

Seen as close to the conservative Popular Party (PP), which has taken a hard line against Catalan separatists, Marchena has trodden carefully in a trial he knows is under the domestic and foreign spotlight.

“At stake is his prestige, the prestige of the Supreme Court as well as the international image of Spain’s judiciary,” Xavier Vidal-Folch, deputy director of the El Pais daily, told Spanish radio on Wednesday.

He described Marchena as handling the proceedings “with great skill, with a little subtle irony and a lot of flexibility”.

“Let’s be serious,” Marchena told one defence lawyer when refusing his demand to have Catalonia’s former president Carles Puigdemont — the main protagonist of a failed secession attempt in 2017 who fled Spain — testify as a witness.

“You can’t be a witness in the morning and a defendant in the afternoon.”

But the 59-year-old judge, who has since 2014 presided over the criminal division of the Supreme Court, has also reprimanded prosecutors for some of their questions.

He also cut short the popular prosecution, a Spain-specific set-up that allows any citizen or organisation to be an accuser in court alongside public prosecutors — in this case far-right party Vox.

Marchena warned the lawyer representing Vox that he would not allow “an ideological debate” in the courtroom.

– An eye on Europe –

The trial against 12 Catalan separatist leaders and activists, nine of whom are accused of rebellion, raised passions even before it started on February 12.

It is fiercely rejected by independence supporters in Catalonia but also fiercely supported by many Spaniards who watched aghast as Catalonia’s executive tried to break from Spain in October 2017.

Such were the accusations of partiality levelled against Spain’s judiciary that the proceedings are being broadcast live on television in an effort at transparency.

And Marchena has showed a degree of leniency towards the defendants.

When the popular prosecution asked him to tell one defendant to remove a yellow ribbon he was wearing that has come to symbolise the independence movement’s cause, he overruled it.

On the first day of the trial, Marchena “gave time and absolute freedom to all sorts of arguments”, legal or political, from the defence lawyers, says Celso Rodriguez Padron, spokesman for the conservative-leaning Magistrates’ Professional Association.

To support some of his decisions, Marchena has referred to legal precedents set by the European Court of Human Rights, knowing the defendants will likely take the case to the European body, says Ignacio Gonzalez Vega, spokesman for the progressive Judges for Democracy professional association.

– WhatsApp controversy –

Even before the trial, Catalan independence supporters were wary of Marchena, who will be writing up the sentence at the end.

Some of those on trial tried in vain to recuse him, claiming he was impartial and had alleged links to the PP, in power at the time of the secession bid.

They cited as an example a leaked WhatsApp message by conservative senator Ignacio Cosido who in November welcomed the promotion of Marchena at the head of the Supreme Court.

Cosido said it would allow the conservatives to “control” the court “behind the scenes”, raising doubts over Marchena’s independence.

After the controversy this generated, Marchena gave up the promotion and remained at the head of the criminal division of the Supreme Court.

Gonzalez Vega tells AFP Marchena is indeed a conservative judge.

But his supporters point to his track record as a prosecutor before he was named Supreme Court judge in 2007, and since then.

He “is a very well qualified magistrate, and there is no doubt over his independence,” says Julio Perez Gil, a professor of procedural law at the University of Burgos who knows him personally.

Share article
Tags: Separatist leadersSupreme CourtSpainCatalanManuel Marchena
Previous Post

Zambia opposition to report president’s ‘violence’ to ICC

Next Post

Mixed reactions to Budget Speech

Related Posts

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy met with British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak.

‘Give us wings’, Ukraine’s Zelenskyy pleads on European tour

8 February 2023, 8:38 PM
Members of the Algerian rescue team and Syrian army soldiers search for survivors at the site of a damaged building, in the aftermath of the earthquake in Aleppo, Syria February 8, 2023. REUTERS/Firas Makdesi

SA’s Ambassador to Syria condemns harsh sanctions imposed by Western countries

8 February 2023, 2:06 PM
Rescuers carry a woman after she was evacuated from under a collapsed building following an earthquake in Kahramanmaras, Turkey, February 7, 2023.

WHO estimates death toll from Türkiye and Syria quake at 20 000

8 February 2023, 8:41 AM
US President Joe Biden

American democracy, while bruised, has remained unbroken: Biden

8 February 2023, 5:44 AM
An aerial view shows collapsed and damaged buildings after an earthquake in Hatay, Turkey, February 7

Turkey-Syria quake death toll passes 7 800

8 February 2023, 5:20 AM
People look amid rubble as the search for survivors continues following an earthquake in Hatay, Turkey, February 7, 2023.

Rescuers in race against time as Turkey-Syria quake death toll passes 5,000

7 February 2023, 3:36 PM
Next Post
Minister of Finance Tito Mboweni delivers his 2019 Budget Speech in  Parliament.

Mixed reactions to Budget Speech

Most Viewed

  • 24hrs
  • Week
  • Month
  • Green comet to be visible from SA next week
  • SA Weather Service warns of maximum temperatures in Cape Town
  • VIDEO: Mabuza resigns as SA Deputy President
  • Budding Stellenbosch FC star reportedly stabbed to death
  • Several areas in Gauteng without water
  • Parts of the Northern Cape to be exempted from rolling blackouts
  • Green comet to be visible from SA next week
  • Registration at Unisa closes on Friday, but management says no need to panic
  • VIDEO | St Benedict College’s Matric learner gets 11 distinctions
  • Limpopo matriculant from child-headed household attains diploma pass
  • Several areas in Gauteng without water
  • ‘Sisulu should be fired for her unacceptable behaviour’
  • I knew nothing about the Tottenham Hotspur deal: Sisulu
  • Stern warning to members who may try to disrupt SONA proceedings
  • Police Minister approached us about the assassination plot: EFF

LATEST

Soldiers guard positions near the Naaba Koom military base in Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso. (File)
  • Africa

Gunmen kill two MSF workers in west Burkina Faso


Power lines
  • Eskom rolling blackouts
  • Business

Six Eskom power stations identified as primary cause of rolling blackouts


Shopping cart loaded with grocery.
  • SONA 2023
  • Business

CEOs of CGCSA-member companies highlight rising cost of doing business in SA


  • SONA 2023
  • Politics

Disruptions to President’s SONA will be firmly dealt with: Mapisa-Nqakula


[FILE PHOTO] Learners seen playing during their school break.
  • South Africa

Plans to fast-track pit toilet eradication at schools on track


Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy met with British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak.
  • World

‘Give us wings’, Ukraine’s Zelenskyy pleads on European tour


Weather

  • About the SABC
  • Contact Us
  • Jobs
  • Advertise
  • Disclaimer
  • Site Map

SABC © 2023

No Result
View All Result
  • SOUTH AFRICA
  • POLITICS
  • BUSINESS
  • SPORT
  • AFRICA
  • WORLD
  • SCI-TECH
  • LIFESTYLE
  • FEATURES
  • OPINION

© 2022

Previous Zambia opposition to report president’s ‘violence’ to ICC
Next Mixed reactions to Budget Speech